Friday 24 October 2014

Tony Rayns (International Reception)

Film historian, scholar and critic, with a particular specialisation towards East Asian cinemas. Was, in the 1980s, one of the most prominent champions of the Chinese New Wave films.


Relevant books/essays/articles:
The New Chinese Cinema: an Introduction (London: Faber & Faber, 1989)


Relevant quotes:
  • "The trouble is, even “smart” people in Western countries know next to nothing about China’s modern history, and apparently lack the empathy to understand what it’s like to live in the space between authoritarian government and out-of-control profiteering. This wouldn’t matter a toss, of course, except that serious-minded Chinese filmmakers need a global audience to survive. There’s no state support for the “art” sector in Mainland cinema (both Taiwan and Hong Kong do now offer modest subsidies to selected filmmakers), and the all-powerful market with its new 18-screen multiplexes has no time for “art.” Worse, despite pressure, China still hasn’t introduced a proper ratings system—the thinking seems to be that all films should be “suitable” for all ages—while political and military censorship processes continue to exert a strong grip. Hence the need that Jia and his contemporaries have for distribution abroad. That’s getting harder to find, and less lucrative—as even the likes of Zhang Yimou have discovered. No Chinese filmmaker has been more thoughtful or adventurous in battling all these adversities than Jia Zhangke. Accepting commissions, as long as they allow him a completely free hand, is one of the main planks of his creative survival strategy. You’d think “smart” people would get it. Let’s open a parenthesis for a moment to consider the sad case of Chen Kaige. In 1988 Chen took his best film, King of the Children, to Cannes. He came away not only without a prize but also dumbfounded to discover that the huge majority of Western viewers knew nothing about the Cultural Revolution (and so weren’t able to supply the off-screen realities the film took as given) and had absolutely no sense of either the burden of China’s traditional culture or the imperative in the late ‘60s to follow a strict Maoist line. Since then, Chen has struggled in film after film to find ways of dealing with Chinese issues that will be intelligible to foreigners. He tried mythic abstraction (Life on a String, 1991), sexualized melodrama (Farewell My Concubine, 1993; Temptress Moon, 1996) and historical spectacle (The Emperor and the Assassin, 1998) before abjectly surrendering to Mammon with riffs on Billy Elliot (Together, 2002) and Lord of the Rings (The Promise, 2005). (He’s also struggled to overcome his inhibitions about dealing with sex, but that’s another story.) This sorry tale is just one of the many negative examples that Jia Zhangke has before him when he considers how to go on producing credible and innovative cinema in China. Close parenthesis." - in CinemaScope (http://cinema-scope.com/currency/currency-i-wish-i-knew-jia-zhangke-china/)
  • "A dozen of the most innovative and exciting films made anywhere in the world in the last few years have come from China… These films have won Chinese cinema a much higher international profile than it has ever known before. The irony underlying these gains is that several of the ‘new wave’ films are now better known abroad than they are at home, where they have been attacked both for their failure at the box-office and for their suggestions of ideological deviation from CP orthodoxies." (from essay in Perspectives on Chinese Cinema)

Interviewed London august 2016.

Monday 20 October 2014

Domestic criticism/attacks (Domestic Reception)

  • Ideological attacks were raised on the validity of the 'New Chinese cinema' around 1987, by the likes of Wu Yiqong, the then-head of the financially troubled Shanghai Film Studio. Wu dragged politics into the picture by accusing the films of the Fifth Generation of failing to 'serve the people' because the films were regarded as inaccessible and obscure. This provided ammunition for politicians who at that period were in a cycle of stamping down so-called 'bourgeois liberalism'. Certain filmmakers from the older generations joined in on these critiques, such as the likes of Xia Yan, ironically himself an innovative young director who'd come up against the system in the 1930s. E.g. Wu Yiqong quote: "One of the biggest problems in the theory world today is getting the value of film all upside down. Which comes first – its existential value or its essential value? If an artist makes a film without taking the audience into account at all, then how can they see the film’s essential value as a medium for popularising things with the masses?"
  • The films were also attacked on economic grounds, as not being able to win back any more at the box office (the weaknesses of the Chinese film distribution system are relevant here), meaning their production was seen as not justifiable on financial terms, although Chris Berry reminds us that government-commissioned reform films taking up much higher budgets and counting for 40% of annual productions (as opposed to 10-15% for Fifth Generation or 'exploratory' films) lost money but nobody dared to criticise those for the same reasons.
  • Accusations of orientalism and of making films deliberately trying to appeal to foreigners and foreign film festivals have been common. See for instance the comments of Dai Qing concerning Raise the Red Lantern.

Stylistic and Aesthetic Similarities across the New Waves (Cross-connection)

The propensity for rural settings and folk/peasant-based influences

Examples(folk/peasant traditions): The Horse Thief, On the Hunting Ground, Gabbeh, A Mongolian Tale, Song of Tibet, Yellow Earth ...
Examples (rural setting): All the above + Abbas Kiarostami films, Hou Hsiao-Hsien films, Samira Makhmalbaf films,

Note the influence of Wu Tianming at the Xi'an Film Studio in legitimising the genre termed 'western' as any film based in one of the autonomous provinces of China. This led to the production of several more rural-based films, but really there were other reasons behind this common feature of many Fifth Generation films in the 1980s. Firstly, these directors had all been sent to the countryside as zhiqing during the Cultural Revolution and had formative experiences there which were a key source of their desire to express themselves. Secondly, they had been sent to, and found more freedom at, smaller regional studios in the provinces.

Sunday 19 October 2014

Life on a String (Film)

1991. Dir: Chen Kaige.


Context:
British-Japanese-Dutch-German-Italian coproduction...





The Film:

  • "My favorite Chen film of the decade, closer to the quiet, tragic beauty of Yellow Earth than the excesses of the later films. This, like Temptress Moon, is hard to follow at first, and assumes some knowledge of Chinese tradition and folklore. There’s also an odd restaurant surrounded by waterfalls that may or not be some metaphysical waystation between this world and the next. The plot follows an old blind musician who wanders around rural northern China, regarded as a holy man by the locals. According to some custom, if a blind musician breaks 1000 strings during his lifetime, he will be able to regain his sight. The old man has a young protégée, who occasionally rages at his blindness and wants to see. The young man falls in love with a local girl, but trouble arises with her parents. Gradually, it’s revealed that while the old man has tried to put love and the desire to see behind him, he still feels tormented by lost love and the promise that his eyesight may return, causing conflict with the young man. Throughout a mysterious figure, who resembles a statue of a God of Death in the temple where the two live, appears in crowds watching the players perform, grinning mysteriously. While the colors don’t pop as much as in Yellow Earth, there are still lots of lovely landscape shots. Appreciation of this film may depend a lot on what you make of the two big sequences where the old man sings (to stop a fight between two villages, and at the end), and your ability to accept its many ellipses that are never quite filled." [CriterionForum, 1990s list thread, Feb 2015]








References:
http://nasharit.ru/video?name=idi_i_poi_/_zhizn_na_strune_/_Life_on_a_String_/_Bian_Zou_Bian_Chang&site=vk&oid=22687267&id=159509512&hash=77673485938ddeb4

http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNTQ0MzY2NzY=.html

Saturday 18 October 2014

Wu Ziniu (Director)

Born: 1953, Lechuan, Sichuan province. Fifth Generation director.

His film The Dove Tree (1985) was the first Fifth Generation film to be banned.


Friday 17 October 2014

The Big Parade (Film)

1986. Dir: Chen Kaige. Cin: Zhang Yimou. Scr: Gao Lili.


Context:
"Director Chen Kaige, cinematographer Zhang Yimou and designer He Qun started work on The Big Parade almost as soon as they had finished Yellow Earth. The film was shot in the spring and summer of 1985 and it went into post-production the normal way in the autumn. It had reached fine-cut stage by November, when the PLA took strong objection to it. Chen Kaige initially refused to modify the film in any way and so it lay substantially complete but unreleasable for nearly a year. Chen finally agreed to make various changes, purely for the sake of his producers at Guangxi Film Studio, to whom he was of course indebted for his break as a director." [Tony Rayns, Monthly Film Bulletin 1988]











Resources:
http://www.ntnu.edu.tw/tcsl/Media_Language/kaige/filmography/dayuebing.html
http://nasharit.ru/video?name=bolshoi_parad_/_The_Big_Parade_/_Da_yue_bing_(_1986_/1987_)_rezh._chen_kaige_/_Chen_Kaige&site=vk&oid=-21996785&id=164879576&hash=1c7d2195ae8a369a
http://www.nytimes.com/1987/07/12/magazine/china-s-cultural-crackdown.html (Contemporary review)

China Film Corporation (Industry)

Based in Beijing, but with branch offices throughout the country. In the 1980s, domestic distribution was a monopoly of the China Film Corporation. It was also responsible for buying and distributing foreign movies, while its import/export department also handles all overseas sales of Chinese films.

Thursday 16 October 2014

Zhang Zeming (Director)

Born: 1951, Guangzhou. Fifth Generation director, although not part of the 1982 graduates of the Beijing Film Academy. He twice tried to get in but twice failed, before getting a job working at the Pearl River Studio in Guangzhou.


http://www.scmp.com/article/641210/also-showing-zhang-zeming